Saturday, October 19, 2013

Methodological review: a critical evaluation of four studies using interviews

Kenny Stancil
GEO 600
18 October 2013

Methodological review: a critical evaluation of four studies using interviews

Introduction
Interviews are a common method for doing qualitative research in geography. Following this short introduction, I assess four studies that use interviews, often in conjunction with other methods, as a way to resolve their corresponding research questions. In so doing, I hope to shed light on what these studies do well, as well as where there may be methodological weaknesses and/or room for improvement. The ensuing investigations are diverse, but what they have in common is that the interviews involve conversing with and/or about people who are exploited, dispossessed, or otherwise oppressed. Cases include: a) regimes of controlling the labor of migrant agricultural workers in Ontario's tobacco industry; b) perceptions of environmentalism among Hispanics in Toronto; c) activism by residents of a neighborhood in Leeds facing gentrification; and d) conceptions of ‘the public’ by academics and participants in public space controversies. After critically evaluating how the researchers go about conducting interviews in their respective quests to sort out various issues, there is a brief conclusion that puts the studies side by side and summarizes this methodological review.

Study 1: Bridi (2013) “Labour Control in the Tobacco Agro-spaces: Migrant Agricultural Workers in South-Western Ontario”
Robert Bridi describes the increasing role of international labor migration programs in moving temporary migrant workers to jobs in various sectors in developed economies, which creates a “vulnerable reserve army of cheap labour, willing to endure low pay, poor working conditions, and non-standard employment practices” (1070). His article analyzes the Seasonal Agricultural Workers Program (SAWP), which employs approximately 30,000 temporary migrant workers from Mexico, Jamaica, Guatemala, the Philippines, and Thailand in the Canadian agricultural sector each year (1070). More specifically, he focuses on SAWP workers in tobacco farming, investigating how labor control is established on two small-scale farms in South-Western Ontario, where more than 90% of the tobacco produced in Canada is grown. In order to answer this question, he “draws upon select responses from interviews with three Mexican and nine Jamaican workers, two union representatives, and two farm owners” (1070).
Bridi explains that the empirical data in the article is based on select responses from a sample of semi-structured interviews, which ranged from one to three hours in length. He utilized a snowballing technique, in which his “initial contacts were researchers, which led to contacts with union representatives, workers, and farm owners” (1077). Between May and August 2010, he “conducted interviews with two union representatives in Rexdale, Ontario; 12 workers in Simcoe, Ontario where the workers socialized on the weekends; and two farm owners in Delhi, Ontario where the workers were employed” (1077). I appreciate that Bridi acknowledges where the interviews took place, since this was actually important to the context of labor control. However, although I do not know if it is customary or acceptable, I wish he had explained how he gained access to the farm owners. It would be nice to know how to approach people who you will later criticize for repressing workers. Was he honest with the farm owners about the aims of his research, or did he only mention some of the information, such as that he was studying the labor process on tobacco farms without mentioning his focus on how labor is controlled?
Bridi does go on to mention that while “the interviews focused on various aspects of the labour process (eg working hours, deskilling, alienation, and coping and resistance), select responses were gleaned to highlight one aspect of the labour process (ie labour control)” (1077). In addition, time and funding limitations caused him to concentrate on two small-scale farms, which resulted in a relatively small sample of SAWP workers and farm owners. One point of confusion for me is Bridi’s claim that despite the small sample, “these findings could be applied to other farms in the region,” which is followed by a claim that “this study does not explore the variability of the labour control mechanisms on different farms. This will differ from one farm to another based on, for example, farm size, level of mechanization, management styles, and so on” (1077-1078). His contradictory stance that the study is simultaneously generalizable to other farms in the region and particular to his specific cases studies is never resolved in the article. Despite this small complaint on my part, Bridi does a great job of using interview responses to describe how the labor control regime is constituted.
First, Bridi describes the multi-scalar factors that control labor before it even reaches the point of production. He argues that working in Canada is viewed by migrant laborers as a temporary hardship that eventually leads to improved living conditions, including better opportunities for their children and extended family, which is followed by relevant statements from workers 7, 5, and 10 (1078). This is related to the regime of labor control, since the SAWP selection criteria require that workers have dependents. That all of the workers interviewed were married with children minimizes dissent and reduces the likelihood that workers will remain in Canada once the work term ends (1079). Second, the SAWP’s numerically flexible hiring practices, dependent on the requirements for a particular season, benefits farm owners who are able to employ on-demand workers only when it is profitable to them. Farm Owner 1 explains that “the program allows me to request migrants as long as I can’t find Canadian workers…depending on the season I hire more of less workers” (1079).
Third, a SAWP arrangement that assigns workers to specific farms and requires transfers to be approved by the Human Resources and Skills Development Canada, the Consulate agent in the home country of the foreign worker, and the farm owner makes it nearly impossible to change employers. As Union Representative 2 explains, this means that “the grower was really pushing the workers who were there” (1079). Fourth, the fact that the farm owners provide housing on or close to the farm limits the mobility of workers and makes “them more available for overtime work” (1080). Fifth, Ontario’s Agricultural Employees Protection Act prevents migrant agricultural workers from unionizing. This leaves migrant workers’ working conditions and labor relations to be negotiated by the Consulates of their home countries. However, as Union Representative 1 explains, “they are not really interested in the workers…this is big business.” They prioritize protecting the program, keeping growers happy, and can quickly replace complaining workers (1080). Last, the ability of the owners to arbitrarily fire workers, resulting in immediate deportation, means that workers are fearful of resisting. As Worker 7 said, the “one worker who stood to the boss [was] sent right back to Mexico…I just keep my mouth shut and do the work” (1080).
Bridi then describes additional forms of control that exist at the point of production. Simple control is carried in three ways. First, the direct observation of workers by the owners “gives me a chance to tell them what to do and see how they are doing, I make sure the work is getting done right and out on time” (Farm Owner 1, 1081). Second, the use of automated tobacco planters allows owners or their family members to monitor the process and increase output. Third, the evaluation of workers by owners and the submission of this evaluation to the recruiting agency in their home countries means that workers must earn the approval of their boss or else be relocated or suspended from the program. Furthermore, the farm owners benefit by being able to “request the best workers that are already familiar with the job duties and require no training.” As Worker 11 put it, “The boss picks the best workers, so even if you work hard it does not guarantee anything; you have to show the boss you’re better than the others” (1082).
Finally, Bridi describes the indirect forms of controlling labor on these two tobacco farms. This “may be achieved when workers are given responsible autonomy,” such as “delegating specific responsibilities to individual workers or groups of workers” (1082). When workers played a more independent role in the production process, “they behaved as though they were participating in a process which reflected their own needs, abilities, and wills, rather than a process aimed at accumulation and profits” (1082). This is reflected by Worker 10 who says that “I do my best to show the boss that Mexican workers work hard and deserve to be in Canada,” and by Farm Owner 1 who says that “I have to trust them to work hard, they are good workers” (1083). Second, owners were able to indirectly control workers more effectively by incorporating lead hands into the teams of workers. The hierarchical structure makes it possible for owners to divide “more skilled from less skilled workers and stratify workers according to power differences.” That the lead hands reported back to the farm owners about the performances of individual workers is confirmed by Worker 5, who says that “You don’t only have to worry about the big boss, but also the little boss…he keeps pushing us to work harder, faster…I guess he wants to keep the big boss happy” (1083).
Bridi’s frequent juxtaposition of statements from the farm owners, on the one hand, and the workers and union representatives, on the other, clearly reveals the class conflict present in the super-exploitation of temporary migrant workers. It also highlights the ways in which the possibilities for workers to organize and engage in oppositional politics are limited by a regime of labor control that exists at the point of production and beyond. Bridi’s methodology is very effective in answering his research questions, and he presents his findings from interviews in a very powerful manner. My only complaint is that Bridi twice quotes the lone Mexican worker on Farm 2 (presumably Worker 10 judging by Bridi’s table). I worry that his position as the only Mexican worker on the farm might make him identifiable if someone pieces together the remaining information about the farm (26 hectares, 8 years participating in the SAWP, 24 years in tobacco farming, 15 total workers, 12 SAWP workers, 4 Jamaican workers). For the sake of Worker 10, I hope that there are enough farms with similar characteristics or that the wrong person does not read this article!

Study 2: Gibson-Wood and Wakefield (2012) “‘Participation’, White Privilege, and Environmental Justice: Understanding Environmentalism Among Hispanics in Toronto”
Hilary Gibson-Wood and Sarah Wakefield’s article explores definitions of and approaches to environmentalism(s) and community engagement amongst the Hispanic population in Toronto. In order to do so, Gibson-Wood conducted a total of eight in-depth interviews with a range of actors including executive directors, managers, program coordinators, activists, and volunteers, all of whom were chosen because they play an important role in guiding environmental initiatives within their respective organizations and within the broader Hispanic community of Toronto. One of Gibson-Wood’s earlier research projects with members of Toronto’s Hispanic population “identified community-level organizations as a key source of information and engagement on environmental issues” (649). In order to learn more about the environmental activities of these organizations, the authors contacted representatives from these agencies. In addition to identifying relevant organizations through existing contacts in the community, the authors also utilized internet searches and published listings, for example the Hispanic Development Council’s list of members and partners. Gibson-Wood and Wakefield’s utilization of a previously-established relationship with community organizations that work with Hispanic residents in Toronto and the subsequent snowballing technique used to identify additional agencies that were relevant to their study seems to be a good methodological approach.
The interviews began by gathering information about the organization, its programs, and the participant’s role within the agency before moving on to discuss “how environmental issues are understood and prioritized in the community, barriers and facilitators to participation, and finally partnerships with other organizations and municipal government” (650). The interviewer was a white Canadian woman who is fluent in Spanish, while seven of the eight interviewees were first-generation immigrants from Latin America (the remaining participant was of Asian descent). Gibson-Wood and Wakefield acknowledge that “this research involved working across a complex landscape of difference, including race, language, culture, and gender,” adding that “it is important to recognize the limits this [dynamic of a white “outsider” conducting interviews with  a racialized group] imposes on the information and experiences shared by respondents” (650).
Of the eight interviewees, the participants came from seven different organizations. The principal author interviewed two individuals at one of the organizations, while only one person was interviewed at each of the remaining six organizations. This means that perspectives were limited to one kind of representative from the community organizations engaged in environmental issues, whether they were directors, managers, coordinators, or rank-and-file members. A weakness of the sample, then, is that different participants in these organizations may have contributed different perceptions on how their communities define, approach, and act on environmental issues based on what kind of work they do in the organization. Given that “the number of community agencies in Toronto that are engaged with the Hispanic community on environmental issues is quite small,” the authors may be right to assert that “this sample represents a large proportion of the agencies in Toronto doing this work” (649). However, the sample is not particularly representative of the potential diversity of opinions within the relevant agencies. Rather than relying on one voice from each organization, the study would have been strengthened had Gibson-Wood and Wakefield sought multiple participants from each agency, preferably inclusive of various kinds of actors, from directors to volunteers.
Taking into account the financial and temporal constraints placed on both the scholars and the activists involved, perhaps group-based interviews (akin to focus groups), would have been fruitful. Indeed, conversing simultaneously with various people from each organization may have yielded interesting insight into possible divergences in how different actors define, approach, and act on environmental issues, based on what kind of activities they engage in—managerial paperwork, door-to-door awareness raising/recruitment, or maybe both? In so doing, there may have been more potential for the co-production of knowledge that could prove useful to activists. If the authors preferred to stick with their chosen methodology, then it would have been useful had they better defined who was speaking for each organization: a leader or an on-the-ground worker. It is important to note whether “the executive director of NGO A said…” or “a volunteer at NGO B said…” On the other hand, the researchers may have been trying to prevent the respondents from being identified, in which case I understand their decisions to withhold information about one’s position in an organization. As Gibson-Wood and Wakefield go on to say later in the article, “future research interviewing members of the Hispanic population themselves could provide further insight on the lived experience of that community” (657).
Insofar as methods are the means by which answers to questions are developed and linked to theory, I find Gibson-Wood and Wakefield’s methodological approach largely successful. Their use of interviews sheds light on the research questions they pose (p. 643), which are: 1) How do organizations offering environmental programming in Toronto’s Hispanic community “view environmental issues, environmentalism(s), and environmentalists, and what can this tell us about participation (or lack thereof) in environmental action/decision-making in the population that they serve”? 2) “What is distinctive about the Hispanic experience in Toronto and in Canada, and what implications might this have for Hispanic environmental activism here”?
Through their research, the authors identify four “mechanisms of exclusion.” First, participation in environmental activism is limited by the economic marginalization of many Hispanics in Toronto. One woman who works at a community health center that serves mostly recent immigrants described the situation faced by her patients with regards to environmental hazards in the workplace. As she explained, undocumented immigrants face an especially precarious situation that increases environmental health risks (such as exposure to chemicals for workers employed in cleaning and construction) yet renders it dangerous to challenge systemic inequality and discrimination (650-651). Thus, when considering the broader structural context and underlying systems of power that produce and reinforce economic marginalization, it is understandable why concern for environmental issues is not seen as a priority for those who are struggling to meet more pressing needs.
Second, the dominant avenues of participation presented by environmental (N)GOs were seen as limiting broader participation in environmental activism by Hispanics in Toronto. Interviewees pointed out a lack of attention to economic and educational inequality implicit in the communication strategies of (N)GOs, for example assumptions made about computer literacy and internet access (652). Based on a response from an interviewee, Gibson-Wood and Wakefield write that “formalized approaches to participation can be disempowering” in that “particular (raced and classed) views of what participation ‘should’ look like” disregard resources (including language)  required to participate, limiting the responsiveness of certain (N)GO actions with respect to the intended population (652).
On the other hand, “participants identified the environmental activities and approaches to engagement being promoted by their own organizations as different from those run through other organizations, sometimes in subtle and sometimes in fundamental ways” (652-653). For example, representatives from community gardens and cycling programs stressed that their initiatives go beyond narrowly defined environmental issues to consider such topics as health and migration, whereas the government in Toronto and Canada more broadly tended to treat environmental and social as separate.
            This is related to the third factor limiting the environmental activism of Toronto’s Hispanic population, which is a narrow definition of ‘environmentalism’ and “what ‘counts’ as environmental action” (654). The framing of solutions to environmental problems as technological or altering individual consumption practices tended to render the environmental knowledge of immigrants as less important (654). Even though more ‘mainstream’ environmental actions “were described as less relevant or accessible,” they “still had an important place in defining what environmental action is” (655).
The last “mechanism of exclusion,” is the perceived whiteness of environmentalism, which is clearly related to economic marginalization. A woman who found it difficult to promote interest in environmental programs at her community center said that she thinks “it has a lot to do with people caring a lot more about raising awareness for non-status, and women’s rights, and union workers, than about environment…It’s a very Canadian, white thing to care about, honestly” (656). Other respondents pointed out the “discussion of ‘whiteness’ and environmentalism within the context of the Hispanic population itself, and the relationship between ‘whiteness’ and immigration status” (656). One interviewee referred specifically to what he sees as Chileans and Argentinians closeness to Europe rather than Latin America. While his comment is a glaring generalization, Gibson-Wood and Wakefield do refer to the concept of “environmental racialization” with regard to environmental injustice in Canada. They argue that it “addresses the fluid, contextual nature of racial meaning in Canada, highlighted in our case study by differing levels of perceived inclusion/exclusion from Canadian environmentalism based on country of origin, immigration status, and “whiteness” across what might otherwise be considered one racial group/community” (658).
One general criticism that I have of the article is that despite sometimes problematizing the tendency to view the Hispanic population in Toronto as one homogenous group, Gibson-Wood and Wakefield seem to do it themselves quite frequently, with constant references to the Hispanic community. Overall, though, this is a mostly effective study from my perspective, and it provides a good example of the successful use of interviews to answer research questions.
             
Study 3: Hodkinson (2010) “Housing Regeneration and the Private Finance Initiative in England: Unstitching the Neoliberal Urban Straitjacket”
            In his investigation of  the private finance initiative (PFI), the Labour government’s key public-private partnership strategy for inner-city regeneration (read: gentrification), Stuart Hodkinson intervenes in the ongoing debate regarding ideal-type versus contingent neoliberalism and what Gibson-Graham calls “strong” versus “weak” theory. Based on a case study of a proposed plan for inner city regeneration through a PFI in the northern English city of Leeds, Hodkinson argues that through the lens of “strong theory,” the PFI “fits the role of an ideal-type neoliberal straitjacket,” but that viewed through the lens of “weak theory,” the structural contradictions of the PFI scheme make it possible for activists to unstitch the neoliberal urban straightjacket (360).
            Hodkinson explains that this project—which began in 2005 as part of an initial 2-year study funded by the British Economic and Social Research Council looking into self-organized, anti-capitalist activism at the grassroots level in the UK—“was undertaken in the more collaborative and spontaneous vein of participatory action research that places people at the active centre of research agendas, and was specifically influenced by traditions of ‘research militancy’ found in Argentinian and Italian autonomist struggles” (368). A PFI housing scheme seeking to open up council housing (the British equivalent to public housing) to increased private ownership and market forces threatened to demolish existing council housing to make land available for private residential development. Tenants opposed these proposals that had the potential to displace hundreds of people. Hodkinson’s engagement started when a local community worker on the Little London council housing estate in Leeds requested support for the group. As Hodkinson puts it in his methodological reflection:

Given the proximity of the neighborhood to the university and the surrounding ‘studentification’ that was a factor behind regeneration, I felt a degree of ‘academic responsibility’ to act and defend what Chester Hartman has called people’s ‘right to stay put’, especially given the enormous human damage wrought by displacement. The research has thus followed a long lineage of scholar activism in geography and beyond that values politically engaged research (368).

His role was to support the official tenants association, the Little London Tenants and Residents Association (LLTRA), by “co-producing processes and outputs relevant to formulating and achieving these local activists’ aims” (368-369). Activities undertaken by Hodkinson were: facilitating and recording minutes at campaign strategy meetings; helping tenants challenge the local authority’s misleading information; co-writing press releases; audio and film recording official meetings and consultation processes; organizing training and advice sessions; and more conventional academic research about the use of the PFI in housing regeneration policy through “interviews with elected councilors, housing officers, and the two bodies separately employed as the Independent Tenants’ Adviser” (369). A great deal of mutual respect and trust seems to have been fostered throughout this two-year collaboration between Hodkinson and the LLTRA, culminating in his formal appointment as their ‘community advisor’. Hodkinson was asked to write about “the tenants’ experience of the regeneration scheme and accompanying consultation process as the basis of an official complaint against Leeds City Council to the local government ombudsman” (369). He relied on the LLTRA’s archives of minutes and documents, individual interviews, focus group-style discussions, conversations with local residents, film footage of public meetings, in-depth analysis of government policy documents and local authority reports (369). The amount of attention dedicated to explaining the methodology is highly appreciated, since it does not always seem to happen, perhaps due to journal requirements, a tendency to take methods for granted, or maybe both. 
            Hodkinson skillfully blends information gleaned from policy documents and interviews with elected councilors and housing officers to shed light on how the PFI housing regeneration model adheres to the principles of neoliberal urbanism explained earlier in the literature review. For instance he portrays how councilors and officers blame the lack of “market forces in the ‘sprawling mono-tenure council estates’ that breed a ‘mono-culture’ of crime and welfare dependency,” and seek solutions in the transformation of public housing into private residential development via public-private partnerships (370). In addition, he does a great job of utilizing the insights of the LLTRA. He conveys how intelligent and politically aware the tenants are when they explain the PFI as “a form of backdoor privatisation that would raise rents and mean service cuts” (371).
            The details that emerge from the case of the PFI in Leeds and the insights of the affected tenants support the so-called strong theory of neoliberalism as an anti-democratic ‘roll-back’ and ‘roll-out’ program of restoring capitalist class power through ‘lock-in’ processes of ‘creative destruction’ and ‘accumulation by dispossession.’ This ‘strong’ theorization of the PFI as a “neoliberal straightjacket” is supported by comments from those interviewed. It almost undermines Hodkinson’s argument that a ‘weak’ theorization of the PFI suggests that its “power to neoliberalise space and place is inherently precarious due to its highly complex private financing model” (360). However, through an analysis of how “tenants’ everyday activism has played a major role in repeatedly forcing back the PFI timetable” (as of October 2010, the scheme was scheduled to begin in summer 2011, 7 years later than initially expected), Hodkinson makes a good argument that exposing the inherent contingency and instability of neoliberalization may be more empowering than the ‘strong’ explanations, which are characterized as disempowering. While I am generally sympathetic to Hodkinson’s argument, it seems that some of the distinctions between “strong” and “weak” theories of neoliberalism may be overstated. I do not think that describing the PFI as an anti-democratic attempt to accumulate by dispossession through creative destruction necessarily reinforces the hegemonic capitalist order, as Gibson-Graham argue such “strong” versions do. Pointing out its unjust nature from a “strong” lens can help expose contradictions that create opportunities for resistance, as the “weak” theory attempts to do. Overall, I found this well-executed paper’s case study to be a good one with which to engage the aforementioned debates. The author employed a very interesting methodology that scholar-activists might try to emulate.

Study 4: Staeheli and Mitchell (2007) “Locating the public in research and practice”
            The objective of Lynn Staeheli and Don Mitchell’s article is to bring clarity to the increasingly complicated discussions of the public and public space by “examining where participants in public space debates ‘locate’ the public—those spheres or realms where participants believe a public is constituted and where public interest is found” (792). In order to do so, they conducted interviews with 25 scholars actively involved in research concerning public space and 63 participants in public space controversies in five U.S. cities, comparing these conceptualizations to the geographic literature on the topic.
            To begin, the literature review consisted of a systematic exploration of the Anglophone, geographic literature published between 1945 and 1998. Staeheli and Mitchell identified 218 articles, book chapters, and books that focused on public space and that were either written by a geographer or published in a geographic journal or book. Definitions of public space, theoretical orientations, empirical foci, and data and methods were evaluated in each article (794). In the literature, Staeheli and Mitchell found a variety of definitions of public space, as well as a variety of reasons describing why public space is important. They determined both the range and frequency of public space definitions and reasons for importance, while stating that multiple options were possible since the potential definitions and reasons for importance are not mutually exclusive. Public space was defined most frequently by its physical characteristics, as well as its nature as a place of interaction and/or contestation. It was seen as important for social function and democratic politics (797-798). This impression was verified through a K-means cluster analysis, from which two clusters emerged. 141 articles were included in the first cluster, which depicted public space as a meeting place characterized by a lack of individual control, important for socialization and identity formation through recreation and casual interactions (798). 74 articles were included in the second cluster, which depicted public space as a meeting place characterized by: negotiation and conflict; accessibility and surveillance; the sharing of ideas; and public ownership, important as “a location for democracy, politics, and social movements” (799).
Next, Staeheli and Mitchell contacted all of the authors of those pieces who have a PhD and who were working in the USA during the interview period. They conducted interviews with the “authors still living, willing, and able to participate,” totaling 25 interviews with academic geographers (794). Two questions arise for me. First, assuming that Staeheli and Mitchell were willing to evaluate the writing of non-PhD holding academics in their review of the literature, why was the possession of a PhD then used as a discriminatory factor in contacting potential interviewees? Though this may not have been terribly consequential, it seems like an unnecessary, self-imposed requirement that may have limited the range of scholarly opinion on the topic. Second, what prevented Staeheli and Mitchell from conducting phone interviews with authors not living in the USA? It seems like this would have resulted in an increased amount of overlap between the academic literature and the scholarly interviews, though I understand if funding and time constraints precluded more interviews with geographers from taking place.
Staeheli and Mitchell asked the interviewees to define public space and talk about its importance as a way to understand how they define ‘the public’. They found that there are nuances “between how geographers write about public space and how they articulate their interest in and knowledge of it” (799). In the interviews, there was a reduction in definitions that emphasized physical space (from 37% in the literature to 8%) and as a site of contestation (from 23% in the literature to 8%), with the stress then placed on public space as a place for interaction that lacks individual control (799). Participating in democratic action remained the most important element of public space, while identity formation and community building/social cohesion increased in importance during the interviews. Functions like walking, gathering, and socializing were downplayed in the interviews (799).
            To better “understand both the nature of public space controversies and specific actors’ roles in them,” Staeheli and Mitchell also conducted interviews in spring 2001 with “government officials, activists, business owners or managers, social service providers, planners, and others” in five U.S. cities: San Diego, California; New York City; Syracuse, New York; Washington, D.C.; and Santa Fe, New Mexico (794). The focus in each city was different, from downtown redevelopment and homelessness in San Diego, to community gardens in NYC, to disputes surrounding public financing for the reconstruction of a shopping mall in Syracuse, to protests and parades in D.C., to changes to the Plaza in Santa Fe (794). In all of the interviews, though, Staeheli and Mitchell “sought to elicit how people framed or defined public space and whether and why they thought it was important…to understand how they conceived of ‘the public’” (794).
            Staeheli and Mitchell identified the public space controversy interviewees through newspaper searches and snowball strategies. They concede that this makes it unlikely that the sample is representative of “how the public as a whole conceptualizes publicity and public space,” though that may be a truly representative sample may be a near-impossibility in this case anyway. However, given the focus on five different public space struggles, their interviews “included a range of people from planners to activists, from business leaders to architects, and from police to interested lay people,” which gives “an idea of the range of conceptualizations” (801). Staeheli and Mitchell explain that the results reflect the fact that they were addressing very different kinds of issues in the five cities and that how people understand publicity is contingent on historical and geographical context, as alluded to in interviews with academics. Furthermore, since there were unequal numbers of people interviewed from each case study, “direct comparisons are rather difficult, although they do provide a rough indication of the importance of particular definitions and meanings in each of the controversies” (804). Amongst the public space interviewees, the most common way to define public space was in terms of ownership (24%), while 13% referred to public space as “a space made through the sweat equity of the public, a definition that did not appear at all in the other two sources,” and zero respondents mentioned a lack of control, though this was a key among many geographers (804). The site interviewees tended to discuss the importance of public space more strongly in terms of community, whereas academics stressed democracy, although both sets of respondents and the literature emphasized the social nature of public space (804).
            Staeheli and Mitchell highlight the significant differences among the five case studies, which are interesting because they reveal the importance of context. In New York City and Santa Fe, public space was considered important to community, and also to politics in NYC. However, in San Diego and Syracuse, more importance was placed on economic development. The presence of homeless people was seen by some as threatening to community, rendering private spaces more conducive to socialization and the formation of a public because those deemed potentially disruptive could be excluded. In D.C., “public space was where democratic freedoms were exercised—and sometimes tested,” though the emphasis was on individual rights and political economy was not mentioned (805-806). A potential methodological question mark arose when Staeheli and Mitchell talked with people from San Diego. Because they “were interested in whether homeless people were perceived to be, or able to act as, part of the public,” they “did not ask people about their definitions of public space, although some people did define it without out asking” (805). At first I thought it was methodologically suspect to not ask the same questions at each site in order to make comparisons. However, on second thought, and given that Staeheli and Mitchell have stressed the importance of historical and geographical context to the ways in which ‘the public’ is conceived, I think it was acceptable for them to adjust their emphasis in the interviews. The point was not to make direct comparisons but to understand how and why different conceptions of public space matter.

Conclusion
Bridi’s sound methodology of interviewing class foes allowed him to make convincing arguments. His juxtaposition of quotations from actors with conflicting economic interests provided insight into the exploitative nature of capitalist social relations, while revealing how repression is exacerbated by the vulnerability of migrant workers enrolled in temporary international labor arrangements such as Canada’s Seasonal Agricultural Workers Program. The inability of migrant workers in Ontario to organize and even raise complaints for fear of termination and deportation back to Mexico or Jamaica benefits tobacco farm owners and sheds light on the relationship between the global inequality fueling migration and regimes of labor control.
Gibson-Wood and Wakefield’s interviews with representatives of organizations working with the Hispanic population in Toronto on environmental initiatives helped them identify four interrelated “mechanisms of exclusion” that limit environmental activism in Toronto’s Hispanic population: economic marginalization; potentially inaccessible forms of participation; narrow definitions of ‘environmentalism’; and the perceived whiteness of ‘environmentalists’. If it were possible, speaking with a broader range of representatives from these organizations could strengthen the methodology and may even facilitate the co-production of knowledge emphasized in Hodkinson’s participatory approach, which also included interviews.
Hodkinson’s engagement with the Little London Tenants and Residents Association permitted him to argue for the importance of a “weak” theorization of neoliberalism that draws attention to “the role of human agency in creating delays and thus increasing bargaining power” with regard to the private finance initiative scheme to regenerate inner-city housing (377). His quotations of elected officials (both through interviews and policy document analysis) reveal the pervasiveness of an ideology that emphasizes the sanctity of market forces and condemns undesirable individuals, while his quotations of affected tenants shed light on what they rightly describe as a deliberate attempt to replace the existing population with more affluent property owners via an undercover privatization scheme. The dispossession inherent in this ‘revanchist’ form of gentrification matches “strong” theories of neoliberalism. That the everyday activism of the tenants has delayed the vicious proposal suggests to me the need to reevaluate the distinctions between “weak” and “strong” theorizing. It seems that the “strong” theorists also point out contradictions in order to highlight opportunities for opposition, thus avoiding the charges of the “weak” theorists that they are disempowering. Methodologically, this study was very interesting and well-done in my opinion. That it responds constructively to an ongoing theoretical debate is an additional strength. 
Staeheli and Mitchell employ a productive mix of qualitative (interviews) and quantitative (categorizing definitions via a K-means cluster analysis) methods. Their attempt to come to grips with how academic and non-academic thinking about the public and public space converge and diverge is welcome. Unlike the other studies, Mitchell and Staeheli do not directly quote their respondents. This would seem strange if not for the fact that they frequently cite their other articles related to public space, which suggests that a more direct engagement with the responses of interviewees may be found there. I find this completely understandable, since the point of this article is to categorize a variety of conceptualizations of the definition and importance of public space in order to bring clarity to the discussion. It is extremely thorough and very well-done from my perspective.  
These four studies reveal the numerous purposes for which the method of interviewing can be used, from Hodkinson’s participatory action research to Staeheli and Mitchell’s taxonomical exercise, and there are more possibilities, too. Given the diversity of the issues explored in the articles reviewed here, it may be a stretch to declare what they share, but I will try: what these methodologies have in common is that interviews (whether with powerful actors, marginalized ones, or both) reveal inequalities and power asymmetries. In so doing, the articles attempt to contribute, to varying degrees, to finding ways to subvert oppressive social relations so as to make possible to construction of more just, equitable, and democratic spaces, from Ontario’s tobacco farms, to Toronto’s environmental justice organizations, to Leeds public housing, to ‘public space’ across the U.S. This may be too broad a conclusion, since not all of the authors were as explicit as Hodkinson in articulating from where alternatives might spring. Nevertheless, normative claims were implicit in the other articles. From these studies, I found that the method of interviewing in general (and conversing with opposing actors in particular) seems to be a fruitful way to unravel class struggles and the role that race and space play in those conflicts.

Works Cited
Bridi, Robert (2013) “Labour Control in the Tobacco Agro-spaces: Migrant Agricultural
Workers in South-Western Ontario” Antipode 45.5: 1070-1089

Gibson-Wood, Hilary and Sarah Wakefield (2012) “‘Participation,’ White Privilege and
Environmental Justice: Understanding Environmentalism Among Hispanics in Toronto” Antipode 45.3: 641-662

Hodkinson, Stuart (2010) “Housing Regeneration and the Private Finance Initiative in England:
Unstitching the Neoliberal Urban Straitjacket” Antipode 43.2: 358-383

Staeheli, Lynn and Don Mitchell (2007) “Locating the public in research and practice” Progress
in Human Geography 31.6: 792-811




Friday, October 18, 2013

Multispecies ethnography

Matthew Rosenblum T. Mutersbaugh GEO 600: Methods in Geography 17 October 2013 Paper #1 Multispecies Ethnography In a forthcoming piece entitled ‘Animals, Plants, People and Things: A Review of Multispecies Ethnography’ (Forthcoming) Laura Ogden, Billy Hall, and Kimiko Tanita define multispecies ethnography as “ethnographic research and writing that is attuned to life’s emergence within a shifting assemblage of agentive beings” (Para. 4). In this way these scholars mean to deploy multispecies ethnography as a methodological tool which is committed to recognizing the interconnectedness of beings. Drawing on a variety of theoretical traditions such as object-oriented ontology, hybrid geography, poststructuralist political ecology, posthumanism, science and technology studies, and others, it is a means of grasping “both… bio-physical entities as well as the magical ways objects animate life itself” (Ibid.). This disposition situates multispecies ethnography firmly in the tradition of Timothy Morton’s (2010) ‘ecological thought’: “The ecological thought does, indeed, consist in the ramifications of the "truly wonderful fact" of the mesh. All life forms are the mesh, and so are all the dead ones, as are their habitats, which are also made up of living and nonliving beings. We know even more now about how life forms have shaped Earth (think of oil, of oxygen—the first climate change cataclysm). We drive around using crushed dinosaur parts. Iron is mostly a by-product of bacterial metabolism. So is oxygen. Mountains can be made of shells and fossilized bacteria. Death and the mesh go together in another sense, too, because natural selection implies extinction” (29). Thus the ‘ecological thought’ is committed to blurring a variety of distinctions such as object and subject, dead and alive, human and non-human, etc., which are fundamental to the project of modernity. As a constitutive element of the ‘ecological thought,’ multispecies ethnography can be thought of as a means of analyzing the processes by which the relationships between entities are formed in ways that exceed their bounded materiality. Ogden et. al.’s use of the term ‘entities’ is no rhetorical flourish, but rather is a purposeful indictment of the hegemonic forms of classification that are alive in a centuries old ecological taxonomy. As such, the forms of analysis we call multispecies ethnographies take the problematization of certain naturalized categories as their raison d’etre, chiefly the human type. As Ogden and her colleagues argue, ‘human’ has served as a nodal point for scholarly research, whereby this uncomplicated subject has become the focus of various strategies for theorizing difference such as race, gender, class, etc. Channeling the work of Jacques Derrida (1978) Ogden et. al. argue that this disposition posits the human as the ‘fixed origin’ (278) whereby human difference is theorized but never collapsed. That is to say that the human is conceptualized in a variety of modalities but it’s very basic identify is solidified in relation to the exterior world of objects and subjects. Contra this framing of the human subject, multispecies ethnography posits the necessity of “seeing the human untethered from its fixed isolation from other beings and things” (Ogden et. al. Forthcoming; para. 7). Rather than seeing human-ness “as a biocultural given” this form of ethnography decenters the human by writing it “as a kind of incarnate essence that comes into being relative to multispecies assemblages” (Ogden et. al. Forthcoming; para. 6). Thus the purpose of the multispecies ethnography is not to analyze the relationship between humans on one hand and animals, plants, and other entities of the other hand, although it is theoretically indebted to early anthropological traditions that did (Kirksey and Helmreich 2010; 549), but rather to show how the relationships between humans and other entities, and indeed any permutation of entities are producing multispecies assemblages which deny the discrete character of what is traditionally thought of as human, or any species at all. The literature base that is representative of the phenomenological encounters described through multispecies ethnographies exceeds the human category and also includes the encounters of nonhuman animals, plants, microbes, and other actants. The proceeding pages provide a partial snapshot of significant contributions to this endevour, within geographical analysis and without. In Das Kaptial Karl Marx (1990) describes human ‘species being’ via their creative function, that capacity which drives toward them the future. He contrasts this with the creative workings of the bee by arguing that humans are able to deploy imagination in their quest to create, whereas the bee is bound to the formulaic workings of its biology. The key distinction between humans and the bee is, for Marx, the role of consciousness in human creation. Problematizing this distinction, Jake Kosek (2010) examines “the militarization of honeybees and the use of ‘the swarm’ as a metaphor by the U.S. military in the ‘war on terror’” (Kirksey and Helmreich 2010;) arguing that humans use ‘the swarm’ of the bee as a notionality for both the construction of bee-type robots and for the strategic use of human troops in the field of battle. Ironically, the difference between human and non-human, which for Marx is “on the back of the bee” (Kosek 2010;) is exploded by Kosek in his explanation of how human strategic endeavors exploit, precisely, the lack of intentionality on the part of bees and their “flexible, decentralized, adaptive form” (Kosek 2010;) in such a way where the semiotic and material figure of the bee becomes both the way of understanding the behavior of humans their products and blurring the distinction that is erected between them . Adam Keul (2013) uses the relationship between humans and alligators in the Atchafalaya River Basin to show the possibilities of bodies sharing and coexisting in space. Through what might be termed a soft anthropomorphism Keul shows how the particularity of the encounter between human tourists and alligators in the context of eco-tours facilitates a blending of (non)human emotions- “both scripted and improvisational…fearful and fearless, passive and aggressive” (3-4). In doing so Keul portrays a situation whereby “the dynamics of these encounters show not only that these animals are shaped by the human world, but also that they reciprocate an impact on us” (2). In this situation both ‘gators and humans are involved in performances that highlight a similar variety of affective dispositions and as such, the difference between the human and non-human becomes hazy; the alligator becomes embodied in ways that are related to by their human compatriots and in doing so the tourist comes to associate with the animality of their other. Amelia More (2012) provides an explanation of how invasive lionfish, fisherman, and fisheries in the Bahamas are bound together in a socially produced relationship which calls into question the naturalized quality of their association. As More has it both lionfish and fisherman are viewed as invasive entities due to their over-consumptive qualities. Because of the seeming impossibility of totally eliminating the lionfish from the Bahamas’ territorial waters, Bahamian ecological managers are described as acquiescing to the existence of these non-native fish by partially naturalizing them and incorporating them into the consumptive economy of the nation by encouraging fisherman, in this case also “imagined to be transgressive overfishers,” (More 2012; 682) to hunt them. In this relationship, both lionfish and their fisherman partners become parts of the natural landscape as it is imagined by those who regulate the territorial waters of the Bahamas- their seemingly invasive habits are thought to serve the interests of the other, they are co-constituting. As More concludes, “because of the social relations of knowledge and practice that create and are created through fishing, then the lionfish is in the process of socially becoming a fishery, part of a fishery, and a fish, in the sense that it can be fished” (Ibid.; 683). While Laura Ogden’s work in Swamplife (2011) precedes her direct engagement with multispecies ethnography, the distinction between that and what she refers to as ‘landscape ethnography’ is tenuous insofar as it refers to “the ways in which our relations with non-humans produce what it means to be human” (28). Of course Ogden makes reference to this seemingly problematic relationship in a destabilizing fashion; in her exploration of ‘gladesmen,’ a group she refers to as “marginalized, illegal, and largely forgotten” (3) she shows how their presence in the Everglades is not only constitutive of a human place in the swamp but the ways in which the swamp reflects back onto the human subject. Thus for Ogden, the Everglades “are assemblages constituted by humans and nonhumans, material and semiotic processes, histories both real and partially remembered” (p. 35). In this way, landscapes and the actants that inhabit them become indistinct; human activity in the Everglades becomes shaped by the myriad non-human actors that inhabit that space just as that space is performed by the naturalized identities of outcast, human, inhabitants. This co-constituting relationship highlights the ways in which multispecies ethnography “is marked by its attentiveness to nonhuman agency- stones, plants, birds and bees have the power to transform the world” (Ogden et. al. Forthcoming; para 43). This paper concludes with a reminder from Isabelle Stengers (2010) who argues that unicorns and other fanciful creatures are easily relegated to the productive capacity of the human imagination, and are subsequently denied an existence in material reality. Unicorns are, in other words, queer subjects for serious forms of consideration. Of course, while unicorns might not be popularly associated with the politics of contemporary life, there was a time when they were; unicorns were the subjects of serious human inquiry with purported material effects just as much as they were products of social construction. While the idea of having our everyday life affected by the existence of unicorns seems strange, the fact that they once figured prominently and thoughtfully in human culture is a fascinating way to examine the virtuality of our multispecies world. Indeed the unicorn is neither purely cultural nor purely nature, but rather a hydrid object which testifies to the creative function of those entities which might not even exist. Works Cited Derrida, Jacques. Writing and Difference. Chicago: University of Chicago, 1978. Print. Keul, Adam. "Embodied Encounters Between Humans and Gators." Social and Cultural Geography Ahead-of-print (2013): 1-24. Print. Kirksey, S. Eben, and Stefan Helmreich. "The Emergence of Multispecies Ethnography." Cultural Anthropology 25.4 (2010): 545-76. Print. Kosek, Jake. "Ecologies of Empire: On the New Uses of the Honeybee." Cultural Anthropology 25.4 (2010): 650-78. Print. Marx, Karl. Das Kapital: Vol.1: A Critique of Political Economy. New York: Penguin Classics, 2007 [1867]. Print. Moore, Amelia. "The Aquatic Invaders: Marine Management Figuring Fisherman, Fisheries, and Lionfish in the Bahamas." Cultural Anthropology 27.4 (2012): 667-88. Print. Morton, Timothy. The Ecological Thought. Cambridge, MA: Harvard UP, 2010. Print. Ogden, Laura, Billy Hall, and Kimiko Tanita. "Animals, Plants, People and Things: A Review of Multispecies Ethnography." (Forthcoming): n. pag. Print. Ogden, Laura. Swamplife: People, Gators, and Mangroves Entangled in the Everglades. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota, 2011. Print. Stengers, Isabelle. "Including Nonhumans in Political Theory: Opening the Pandora’s Box?" Political Matter: Technoscience, Democracy, and Public Life. Ed. Bruce Braun and Sarah Whatmore. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota, 2010. 3-33. Print.

Ethnographies of the State

Ethnographies of the State

States, or institutions that could be recognized as such, have played important roles in the lives of much of humanity for decades if not much longer. The power of the nation-state system is such that territories, populations, or individuals who happen to fall outside the influence of a state for one reason or another are seen as aberrant - the continuing conceptual weight of the state system is thus re-inscribed through concepts of “stateless populations,” “failed states,” and the like. Scholars from various disciplines have dedicated considerable time and energy to studies of the state. In particular, James Scott's anthropology of the state system, Seeing Like a State (1998) has inspired significant work Because of the privileged position held by the state in constructing physical and social space, ethnographies of the state seem, at face value, to be a sensible and even necessary proposition. This essay is an attempt to work through some of these complications that emerge when ethnographies of the state are considered on a deeper level, first examining several complications inherent in ethnographic writing around the state, and then examining several examples of the technique.
As a result of the pervasive influence of state-thinking, it could be said that many ethnographies are, at least partially, ethnographies of the state, in that they necessarily involve examination of the ways in which sovereign power is felt by individuals and communities. The focused application of an ethnographic lens to State organs themselves may also be of use, both in order to gain deeper understandings of the internal logics that inform their actions and in order to provide context that will allow for deeper understandings of the ways in which societies and communities are shaped by their existence within, outside, or on the margins of a state system.
Despite the readily apparent usefulness of an ethnography of the state, however, it is only relatively recently that ethnographic studies of the state have been seriously taken up, as noted by Chatterji in her 2005 report on a workshop that considered the topic. This is likely due at least in part to the numerous difficulties that present themselves to anyone attempting to carry out ethnographies of the state itself. As Chatterji notes, the question of whether ethnographies can be performed on a “Macro subject” remains open. As she reports, the papers presented at the workshop were organized around notionalities of the state that tended to focus on specific state practices or elements of the state-society relationship, complicating the position of any ethnographer who attempts to perform an ethnography of the state as a unit in itself. Furthermore, the nature of the state itself is contested, and some commentators have long argued that the State itself is a phantasm, offering nothing useful to social analysis. Adams goes so far as to argue that “the State as a special unit of social analysis does not exist as a real entity.” (1977, 79). While this perspective has largely been blunted in favor of arguments that recognize a complex interplay of state and nonstate actors in maintaining institutionalized power, difficulties remain, and indeed multiply.
As Trouillot argues in his analysis of the situation confronting anthropologies of the state under neoliberalism, despite the fact that “there is no necessary site for the state, institutional or geographical,” (2001, 127) its relevance is not decreased. In fact, “if the state is indeed a set of practices and processes and their effects as much as a way to look at them, we need to track down these practices, processes, and effects whether or not they coalesce around the central sites of national governments.” (130) Thus, ethnographies of the state must not attempt to focus solely on state organs in themselves, but rather broader views of governmentalities that are spread and shared between official state practice and civil societies – Ferguson and Gupta argue in their move towards ethnography of neoliberal governmentality, that the goal ought to be “an approach that would take as its central problem the understanding of processes through which governmentality (by state and non state actors) is both legitimated and undermined by reference to claims of superior spatial reach and vertical height.” (Ferguson and Gupta 2002, 995) Bringing the state and civil societies together in this way ultimately leads Ferguson and Gupta to question the very distinction imbedded in the term “non-governmental organization.” (995) One particular site for this study, noted by Truillot (2001) should be the state function of bordering and regulating migration, one of the few elements of sovereignty still solely dedicated to the sovereign state under neoliberalism, a concept that will be further discussed below. What follows are readings and analysis of four very different ethnographies of (various) states.

Ferguson and Gupta, in their previously cited article Spatializing States: Towards and Ethnography of Neoliberal Governmentality, use ethnographic research from an Indian state program entitled Integrated Child Development Services (IDCS), which attempts to provide, as the title suggests, a package of well-integrated services that would decrease infant mortality and provide various early-childhood education services. The program, as Ferguson and Gupta describe it, was administered as a relatively traditional top-down bureaucratic hierarchy, with separate contingents of planners, area managers, and a local staff of two individuals per center (again hierarchically divided, of course, into the roles of Worker and Helper). Ferguson and Gupta analyze this formation as presenting interesting questions with regards to the position of the state in a vertical hierarchy as related to life in the villages where the program took place, as the state exists both “above” the village level (through a bureaucratic hierarchy that exerts pressure on and through local-level workers) and “within” the community itself, as the Worker and Helper are situated as being within and “of” the community. (985)
Through the practice of inspections, the IDCS regional offices perform the state-building work that allows it to encompass a broad territory. Administration, data analysis, and other “high-level” functions are carried out in the central office, but through the practice of random, unexpected inspections, the central office is able to perform surveillance and regulation, thus allowing the system to “represent and embody state hierarchy and encompassment” (985, emphasis in original). This representation entails the generation of recursive data-gathering, as one of the primary functions of the Worker and Helper in the villages is to generate and report data on the children they work with – this data is then gathered again by the regional functionaries through their surprise inspections. (987)

Kamran Asdar Ali, in his 1996 ethnography of family planning practices in Egypt, contributes ethnographic research that focuses on family planning policies carried out by the state there under conditions of (neo)coloniality and modernization. Ali attempts to use ethnographic methods to illuminate the ways in which state policy, rather than emanating from a unitary and powerful “state actor” instead are instead contested and implemented by multiple networks of actors on national, local, and international levels. The implementation of the family planning program not only situated the Egyptian state in geopolitical space, but also provided a way for the Egyptian government to “see like a state” in that specific actions that were implemented as part of the program were used not only in order to carry out the explicit goals of the program, but also in order to shore the program (and, therefore, the state itself) up against perceived resistance from Islamic groups. (16) This resistance viewed state attempts to legislate family planning as a cultural affront based on Western imperialism, a claim that not unfounded, as the program was largely funded by the United States. (15)
In its struggle with Islamist groups, the Egyptian state attempted to shore up its legitimacy; Ali writes that, in this framework “contraceptive use may also be […] seen as a symbolic parameter to gauge support and identify opposition by the State.” (19) Contention over the program (and, therefore, the meaning and modernization of the Egyptian state) spanned multiple levels. While family planning programs were largely administered as a response to conceptions of development, modernity, and “proper” state action that originated in the West (see Mitchell 1995) and were funded and promoted by international institutions, the Islamicist resistance to family planning also took on an international dimension, as it was couched in a rhetoric of international Muslim solidarity against Western encroachment, and, as Ali writes, “For many, the internationally assisted family planning programme was part of a larger Judaeo-Christian plot to weaken the Muslims of the world.” (18)

In his study of state centralization in Peru, David Nugent examines conflict and cooperation in state formation from a lens that focuses not on the center of State power itself, but from the margins – in this case, Chachapoyas, a region in the northern sierra where marginalized groups have responded in very different ways to policies of State centralization in distinct historical periods. Specifically, during one wave of centralization in the 1930s, the State was welcomed as a protector, while in the 1970s, state centralization was seen as immoral, and communities actively resisted state centralization. (333)
Nugent's study is framed as an intervention in theoretical debates around conception of state and society, opposing the view in which the State is assumed to be in constant conflict with the populations over which it exerts sovereignty. In order to make this argument, Nugent offers a detailed historical study of regional history that illuminates the ways in which populist movements in the region allied with the state in the 1930s in a shift towards increased state centralization (viewed by locals as more egalitarian), as opposed to the previous, uneasy relationship in power over the remote region was shared between state bureaucracy and a power system held together by networks of local elites. (345-46) However, after a long period of centralization and increasing connection between the capitol in Lima and Chachapoyas, the military junta that took power in 1968 attempted to implement still greater centralized control through direct state appointments of officials, as opposed to the previous formal (electoral) and informal (patronage) systems that had allowed marginal residents to access politics in the center. This arrangement led to mobilizations by local groups that actively resisted the power of the centralized state, to the extent that in Chachapoyas, locally established comunidades de lucha y fe established de-facto autonomy with regard to several infrastructure projects. (354)

Through her dissertation research, which would later be published in multiple forms, Alison Mountz sets out explicitly to undertake “an ethnography of state practices” (2007, 38), performing ethnographic interviews and participant observation in the bureaucratic setting of Citizenship and Immigration Canada, a state agency tasked with administration of immigration law and policy. In two sources, (a book chapter dedicated primarily to the description of her methods entitled Smoke and Mirrors: An Ethnography of the State, and the book Seeking Asylum: Human Smuggling and Bureaucracy at the Border) Mountz goes into great detail not only about the arguments that can be constructed through her examination of Canadian immigration bureaucracy, but also about the difficulty of the method itself. In particular, she highlights the difficulty of working within a bureaucracy that actively defended itself and its secrets against what certain bureaucrats saw as her prodding investigation, while other individuals were perhaps more open than their roles would legally allow (2007, 40). Ultimately, what Mountz finds interesting in her 2007 piece is her own relationship with the State (or, rather, with is bureaucracy): Identities are performed on all sides, and Mountz' own self-conception was picked apart and reconstructed by the bureaucracy at the same time as she attempted to perform her own analysis.
In Seeking Asylum, Mountz applies the research she examined in Smoke and Mirrors, attempting to decompress the impression of a monolithic bureaucracy held by lawyers, immigrant advocates, service providers, and other extra-governmental individuals working on immigration issues (2010, 56). Instead of a fully in-control and functional bureaucratic system able to manage the issues thrust upon it, Mountz finds a “beleagured bureaucracy” (65) in which participants often consider their work in terms of recurring “crisis”, and individual workers are often transferred, resulting in an inability to construct the kind of deep institutional knowledge that is viewed (even by members of the bureaucracy) as necessary for a successful response to human smuggling, part of the organization's stated purpose.

The four ethnographies of the state described above differ substantially in their methodological approach. Ferguson and Gupta make a primarily literature-based argument, specifically attempting to intervene in debates about ethnographies that seriously consider governmentalities in the context of neoliberalism, including relatively brief ethnographic material primarily as an example of the ways in which their theoretical-methodological ideas might be applied. Ali exposes even less explicitly ethnographic material in creating his argument, but makes an argument that directly addresses questions about the shape of relations between the state, non-state actors, and supernational institutions. Nugent, on the other hand, works entirely within one small regional area, but draws conclusions about state-building through historically-comparative work that brings together and analyzes information about a particular region, in ways that may be the most like a traditional ethnography of all the research presented here. Finally, Alison Mountz examines a specific state bureaucracy, performing the most obvious example of an ethnography of a state organ while also demonstrating reasons why this type of research is not more common, as many state bureaucracies are capable of confining or otherwise thwarting researchers, and turning an analytical gaze back upon their own projects and performances.
Despite these differences, the ethnographies I examined bear out many of the preoccupations present in the analyses of state ethnographies with which I opened this essay. Unsurprisingly, none of the ethnographies I read attempted to fully encapsulate a state in and of itself; as expected, the variety of ethnographic subjects examined included significant links between states, international institutions, civil society, and other actors, in ways that suggested a difficulty of fully separating “the State” from the broad field of actors which also institute governmentality. In response to Chatterji and the question of examining the State as “macro subject”, all of the ethnographies I read considered only small fragments of the state system, and built their analysis either outward or inward from that more manageable position. This is to be expected, but also leads to the question of where the frontiers of this type of study might lie. Scott, after all, was able to make sweeping claims about the nature of State practice, which have largely held up to sustained use in various academic projects. However, any attempts to perform ethnographies of a unitary state seem to inevitably lead to hazy questions about the boundaries, both physical and conceptual, of that institution. It may be, then, that ethnographies of the state system are possible, despite the fact that ethnographies of a state remain out of reach for various reasons.




Works Cited
Abrams, Philip. "Notes on the Difficulty of Studying the State (1977)." Journal of Historical Sociology 1.1 (1988): 58-89. Print.
Ali, Kamran A. "The Politics of Family Planning in Egypt." Anthropology Today 12.5 (1996): 14-19. Print.
Chatterji, Roma, Rajni Palriwala, and Meenakshi Thapan. "Ethnographies of the State: Report of a Workshop." Economic and Political Weekly 40.40 (2005): 1-7. Print.
Ferguson, James, and Akhil Gupta. "Spatializing States: Toward and Ethnography of Neoliberal Governmentality." American Ethnologist 29.4 (2002): 981-1002. Print.
Mitchell, Timothy. "The Object of Development: America's Egypt." Power of Development. Ed. Jonathan Crush. London: Routledge, 1995. 129-57. Print.
Mountz, Alison. Seeking Asylum: Human Smuggling and Bureaucracy at the Border. Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota, 2010. Print.
Mountz, Alison. "Smoke and Mirrors: An Ethnology of the State." Politics and Practice in Economic Geography. Ed. Adam Tickell, Eric Sheppard, Jamie Peck, and Trevor Barnes. London: SAGE, 2007. 38-49. Print.
Nugent, David. "Building the State, Making the Nation: The Bases and Limits of State Centralization in "Modern" Peru." American Anthropologist 96.2 (1994): 333-69. Print.
Scott, James C. Seeing like a State: How Certain Schemes to Improve the Human Condition Have Failed. New Haven: Yale UP, 1998. Print.
Trouillot, Michel-Rolph. "The Anthropology of the State in the Age of Globalization: Close Encounters of the Deceptive Kind." Current Anthropology 42.1 (2001): 125-38. Print.